The Magic of Dynamic Asset Allocation

Why Choose Dynamic Asset Allocation Over Static Allocation?

The magic of dynamic asset allocation across four asset classes: equity, debt, gold and real estate.
Image description

Title: The Magic of Dynamic Asset Allocation. Subtitle: Equity, Debt, Gold & Real Estate. Four tiles in a two-by-two grid, one for each asset class: Equity (rising bar chart with an upward arrow) | Debt (certificate with a seal) | Gold (gold bar) | Real Estate (house). The image introduces the four asset classes covered by a dynamic asset allocation strategy.

What Is Asset Allocation?

You must have observed that street vendors often sell unrelated products – such as raincoats and sunglasses? Initially, it seems odd. After all, when can a person buy both items at the same time? Probably never – and that’s the point. Street vendors know that when it’s raining, it’s easier to sell raincoats but harder to sell sunglasses. And when it’s sunny, the reverse is true.

Asset allocation is a strategy of diversifying the investments in different asset classes like equity, debt, gold, real estate. Dynamic asset allocation is an investment strategy wherein the investor buys and sells the different investments in order to keep the allocations based on predefined parameters.


Why Dynamic Asset Allocation?

Why would a street vendor often sell unrelated products? By selling both items – in other words, by diversifying the product line – The vendor is reducing the risk of losing business on any given day. Dynamic Asset allocation is similar to the above example by investing in equity, debt, fixed deposit, gold, real estate, etc., investment risk gets minimized and superior return are generated for each unit of risk taken.

Dynamic Asset Allocation Based on Market P/E Ratios

Let us know look at Dynamic Asset Allocation between debt and equity instruments based on P/E ratios (price to earnings). The price-to-earnings ratio (P/E ratio) is the ratio for valuing a company that measures its current share price relative to its per-share earnings (EPS). The price-to-earnings ratio is also sometimes known as the price multiple or the earnings multiple.

Since the long term average P/E ratio of the Sensex is around 18, we have considered the start points around dates where the P/E ratio was close to 18. An initial investment of ₹ 1,00,000/- is completely invested in equity and 40% of the corpus is shifted to debt instruments when the market P/E reaches 24 times to protect the portfolio. Higher market PE ratios indicate overvaluation and studies indicate that returns start to reduce.

Expensive valuations are very often followed by stock market corrections and when the market P/E ratios reach attractive levels, the entire debt portion of investments is shifted back to equities around 16 P/E ratio. This rebalancing exercise from equity to debt and then back to equity is done every time the market reaches the above P/E levels.

The below chart illustrates the returns generated from the 60:40 equity debt dynamic asset allocation strategy compares the returns generated without the asset allocation strategy.

Bar chart: a 60:40 equity-debt dynamic portfolio shows higher values than 100% equity at all seven dates, Jul-99 to Oct-11.
Image description

Title: Performance Comparison - 100% Equity v/s 60:40 Equity Debt Dynamic Asset Allocated Portfolio. Grouped bar chart; the vertical axis runs from ₹0 to ₹20,00,000 in steps of ₹5,00,000. Teal bars show 100% Equity and orange bars show 60:40 Equity Debt. Data table below the chart (100% Equity; 60:40 Equity Debt): first column, no date: 0; 0 | Jul-99: ₹6,22,767; ₹15,52,292 | Apr-01: ₹8,03,834; ₹13,42,65 (last digit not legible in the image) | Nov-04: ₹4,53,752; ₹7,71,767 | Dec-05: ₹3,01,004; ₹5,11,966 | Jun-08: ₹2,10,140; ₹2,41,079 | May-09: ₹1,93,420; ₹2,21,897 | Oct-11: ₹1,63,058; ₹1,85,269. The 60:40 portfolio is higher at every date. The gap is widest at Jul-99 and Apr-01 and narrows at later dates, and both series generally decline from Apr-01 onward.

An investment of ₹ 1,00,000/- in Jul-99 in Dynamic Asset Allocated Portfolio returned ₹ 15,52,292/- as on 19th March 2020, compared to ₹ 6,22,767 generated by investment in a Sensex tracked index fund. The Dynamic Asset Allocated Portfolio outperformed the Sensex tracked index fund by up to 250%.

Bar chart: a 60:40 equity-debt dynamic portfolio returned more than 100% equity at all 7 dates from Jul-99 to Oct-11
Image description

Title: Performance Comparison - 100% Equity v/s 60:40 Equity Debt Dynamic Asset Allocated Portfolio. Grouped bar chart with a vertical axis from 0.00% to 20.00%, and a data table below it. Date: Jul-99 | Apr-01 | Nov-04 | Dec-05 | Jun-08 | May-09 | Oct-11. 100% Equity (teal bars): 9.22% | 11.61% | 10.33% | 8.01% | 6.49% | 6.24% | 5.95%. 60:40 Equity Debt (orange bars): 14.11% | 14.67% | 14.63% | 12.09% | 7.74% | 8.19% | 7.56%. At every date the 60:40 portfolio shows a higher figure than 100% equity. The gap is widest from Jul-99 to Dec-05 (about 3 to 5 percentage points) and narrows from Jun-08 onward, and both series are lower in the later dates than in the earlier ones.

The CAGR (Compounded Annual Growth Rate) of the Dynamic Asset Allocated Portfolio is up to 5% more than invest and forget equity investment in the Index fund. It can be observed that the return differential increases as the number of years increase; from a difference of 1.61% to 4.91% per year.

While the above strategy sounds very simple to implement, what spoils the party for most investors is their behaviour. It is hard for investors to come out of equity when there seems to be a party at the stock markets every day. It is even harder to stay on the side lines and watch the market gain 20 % – 40% from the date you have changed your asset allocation.

Our recent past is a good reminder of how the markets work. The stock markets reached expensive valuations around the end of 2017 and remained at those levels until the early months of 2020. We have now seen, as in the past, markets correcting and reaching attractive levels. And those who have followed this strategy irrespective of the market temptations stand to gain the most.

The role of a financial adviser in designing your portfolio and subsequent re-balancing can’t be emphasized more. If you have one great, connect with him/her at see how you can implement this, if you don’t, it is time you approach a Fee-Only Financial Planner to help you chart out a strategy that connects with your circumstances, aspirations and goals.

Calendar Icon Book Your Free Introductory Call

Recent Blogs

Best NRI Bank Accounts in India: Complete Guide

Compare NRE, NRO, FCNR, GIFT City and offshore accounts to understand their tax benefits, repatriation rules and suitability for NRIs.

How Does Inflation Impact Retirement Planning?

Learn how inflation impacts retirement savings, income and purchasing power, with strategies to build an inflation-adjusted retirement plan in India.

3 Ways to Invest Using a Minor Account

Learn how to invest using a minor account for your child's future, including PPF, SSY and mutual funds, with key benefits and account requirements.

How Inflation Erodes Wealth and What You Can Do About It

Learn how inflation erodes wealth, reduces purchasing power, impacts savings and investments, and how to protect your finances from rising costs.

A Single Parent's Financial Journey From Tragedy to Triumph

Learn how single parents can manage finances, build an emergency fund, improve insurance coverage, and plan for their child's future.

Long-Term Impact of Personal Loans on Wealth Creation

Learn how personal loans and credit card debt affect savings, investments, and long-term wealth creation, with practical ways to manage debt.

ETFs vs Mutual Funds: Which Is Better?

Compare ETFs vs mutual funds based on costs, trading, flexibility, pricing, and suitability to choose the right investment option for your goals.

Estate Planning in India: A Complete Guide

Learn about estate planning in India, including wills, trusts, powers of attorney, healthcare directives, and beneficiary nominations.

9 Steps to Save for Your House Down Payment

Discover 9 practical steps to save for your house down payment, choose suitable investments, manage risk, and build your home-buying fund.

Child Education Planning: Costs and Investment Strategies

Understand child education costs, inflation, investment options, SIP planning, and strategies to build a corpus for your child's higher education.

7 Steps to Choose the Right Investment Products for Your Financial Goals

Confused about how to choose investment products? Follow these 7 expert-backed steps to align your investments with your financial goals and risk profile.

Investing During a Market Crash: What the Data Really Shows

Should you invest during a stock market crash? See historical Sensex data on returns post-crash and learn why panic-selling hurts investors most.

Dynamic Asset Allocation: What It Is & Why It Works

What is dynamic asset allocation and how does it work? See how a P/E-based equity-debt strategy outperformed the Sensex by up to 250% since 1999.

Understanding Wills: Elements, Types & Why They Matter

What makes a will legally valid in India? Learn its essential elements, types, importance, and what happens to your estate if you die without one.

Should You Prioritize Insurance Before Investing?

Confused about whether to buy insurance or start investing first? Learn why risk management through life, health, and disability cover should come before investments.

Are Index Funds the Right Choice for You?

Wondering if index funds are right for you? Learn why chasing top-performing mutual funds fails and how index funds simplify long-term investing.

Goals Based Investing vs Market Volatility: A Complete Guide

How does a goals based investment approach help during market volatility? Learn why linking investments to your goals beats reacting to market swings.

The Right Way to Calculate Your Life Insurance

How much life insurance do you really need? Learn the Income Replacement and Need Based methods to calculate the right cover for your family.

REITs Explained: Types, Taxation & How to Invest

What are REITs and how do you invest in them in India? Learn types, tax rules, pros and cons before adding real estate exposure to your portfolio.

Right Time to Buy Your Dream House: A Complete Guide

When is the right time to buy your dream house in India? Explore 4 key factors — economic conditions, interest rates, market trends, and finances.

The Right Time to Invest During a Market Correction

We are all shaken, shaken by the ferocity of the fall in the stock markets. Never have we seen a correction of this magnitude in such a short period.

Why Stock Markets Will Remain Volatile?

The reason why stock markets fluctuate revolves around the theory of demand and supply. If more people want to buy a stock, its market price will increase.

What Is a Super Top-Up Health Insurance Policy and How Does It Work?

Base Policy and Super Top Up Policy are two commonly used options while taking Health Insurance. Health insurance is an important tool to safeguard your financial well-being against unexpected medical expenses. As medical treatments become more expensive

Limited Pay vs Regular Pay — Which Life Insurance Premium Option Is Right for You?

Limited pay vs regular pay – it is easy to get confused between options for your life insurance premium payment. While Life insurance plays a crucial role in securing the financial future of your loved ones.

What Should You Do With Your Life Insurance Policy?

In Indian families, pressure to buy traditional life insurance policies can be strong and multifaceted. Parents often play the “security card,” emphasizing the importance of safeguarding their child’s future and highlighting potential future burdens or painting a picture of an uncertain future without the policy.

Comprehensive Guide on Home Loan Overdraft Facility

Imagine a financial tool that combines the stability of a home loan with the flexibility of an overdraft account – that’s precisely what the Home Loan Overdraft Facility entails.

How to Choose from Different Gold Investment Options

Confused about gold investment options in India? From physical gold to SGBs, this guide compares costs, tax rules, and returns to help you make the right choice.

Index Funds - Advantages, Risks & Suitability

Index Funds are an investment instruments that are based on stock market indices like Sensex or Nifty. These funds are built using a pre-set basket of stocks from different sectors of the economy with predefined weights.

Direct Funds vs Regular Funds - Are Direct Mutual Funds better ?

Confused between direct and regular mutual funds? Compare expense ratios, NAV, and returns to find out which plan helps you grow your wealth long-term.

SSY Interest Rates, Tax Benefits, & Withdrawal Rules

Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY) is an initiative launched by the Government of India as part of its Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao campaign, (Save the Girl Child, Educate the Girl Child).

7 Types of Financial Ratios to Assess your personal finance & ways to improve them

Understanding the 7 types of financial ratios is a vital exercise that individuals should undertake to assess the state of their financial well-being.

What Should you do with your 401K Account if you Move Back to India

Moving back to your home country after years of working in the US is an exciting chapter. However, it also comes with its own set of financial considerations, especially when it comes to your US retirement savings.

What Are ULIP Charges and How Do They Work

Know about ULIP charges in India covering mortality, policy admin, switching, surrender, and guarantee fees to help you decide if ULIP is worth investing in.

Key Features of NPS (National Pension Scheme)

The National Pension Scheme is a government-sponsored retirement savings plan introduced in India in 2004. It provides a structured approach for individuals to build a retirement fund by making regular contributions.

ESOPs vs RSUs vs ESPPs - Understand the 7 key differences

In today's competitive Indian job market, companies are increasingly turning to equity compensation plans to attract and retain top talent.

12 Risks of Investing ESOPs/RSUs/ESPPs

Imagine your future self, financially secure thanks to a hefty chunk of your employer's stock, a reward for your dedication and hard work.

What Should You Do With Your Life Insurance Policy Decision

Confused about what should you do with your life insurance policy? In Indian families, pressure to buy traditional life insurance policies can be strong and multifaceted.

5 Proven Ways to Build Stable Post Retirement Income in India

Retirement brings major changes in income and life. Investments and savings can help you meet your needs, but a steady income is still essential for daily expenses and regular cash flow.

12 Must Follow Financial Practices Before Moving Abroad

When one is leaving the familiar shores of India for a new life abroad, it may be both exciting and daunting. It's exciting to pack up your bags and head out on a new adventure, but one of the biggest challenges you will face is getting used to a new financial environment.

5 Reasons to Prefer a Fee-Only Financial Planner in India

The term "financial planner" is used often and very loosely. In India, many people call themselves financial planners, the insurance agent, the mutual fund distributor,

How do Financial Planners & Advisors Get Paid in India?

SEBI (Securities Exchange Board of India), with its latest amendments to Registered Investment Adviser (RIA) Regulations, mandates that all registered financial planners can charge only on two bases. A Financial Planner can either charge a fee for financial planning or earn from distribution of financial products.

How to Choose The Best Financial Advisor In India

If you are confused about how to choose the best financial advisor in India, you can thank the Securities Exchange Board of India (SEBI).

6 Reasons to Review Your Financial Plan for Better Financial Health

Reviewing your financial plan matters as much as using a trusted navigation system. When you move forward without regular reviews, you risk heading in the wrong direction.

SEBI's mandatory disclosure requirement

SEBI Disclosures